Do not fear, the original (and still the best) Aggregator sites are here to stay!
Hat tip to reader Simon M. suggesting that I subscribe to the RSS feed for each announcement Geeklist. It worked perfectly!
I no longer need someone to email me the list each month. Thank you Simon!!!
WGOYT Leaders
Leaders are calculated based on unique entries each month. A unique entry is a single game (or one of its expansions) by a single user in a single month. This eliminates multiple entries for a game by the same user during a month (an acceptable practice, but one that dilutes the stats).

As of February 2021 (applied retroactively), expansions are counted has having played the base game.
Geeklists
Top 20 Uniques
221 - December 2012
219 - June 2013
215 - February 2013
209 - March 2013
208 - May 2011
205 - April 2013
195 - December 2010
193 - March 2012
193 - May 2013
187 - November 2013
184 - February 2012
182 - January 2013
178 - November 2012
178 - October 2015
178 - January 2018
176 - November 2017
171 - September 2011
171 - July 2012
169 - August 2013
169 - February 2014
*** current month
Top 10 Actual
229 - February 2013
227 - December 2012
225 - June 2013
218 - March 2013
213 - May 2011
213 - April 2013
198 - December 2010
197 - March 2012
196 - May 2013
193 - February 2012
*** current month
Top 10 # Games
170 - June 2013
160 - December 2010
157 - May 2013
154 - December 2012
152 - March 2013
151 - November 2013
149 - November 2012
148 - May 2011
148 - January 2018
147 - February 2015
*** current month
Top 10 # Users
Top 10 # New Users
35 - October 2015
23 - October 2010
23 - December 2010
22 - February 2012
19 - January 2011
19 - February 2011
18 - November 2010
16 - November 2012
15 - May 2011
14 - March 2012
after 12 months
*** current month
Yearly Leaders
Top 10 Uniques/Month
Users
Top 20 <summary> Authors
Top 20 Active
Last 60 Days
All-Time Top 50
880 - airjudden
784 - wifwendell
617 - seanmac
438 - sushidog
433 - Joshuaaaaaa
350 - greatredwarrior
336 - Herr Dr
336 - SBGrad
335 - catosulla
300 - ermj1986
299 - bbhalla
280 - alexisW
241 - petegs
234 - barteus
183 - moujamou
172 - pierfederico
167 - gamer72
165 - Rindis
164 - zautman
162 - desertfox2004
160 - zeotter
155 - gohrns
152 - Hattusilis_III
134 - sherron
131 - billyboy
131 - Meisterchow
127 - aeneas2467
122 - servo19
121 - jwquinn
114 - Aussie550
114 - knoel
113 - Moruya23
110 - kubaman
106 - dasher47051
105 - rvc13
103 - grouchysmurf
102 - citizen k
102 - pete belli
98 - peacmyer
97 - dmartin1982
95 - jcurtis55
90 - patton55
89 - Atraxrobustus
89 - Hatricvs
89 - Zigihogan
88 - ad79
86 - ElFluppe
84 - jakinney
84 - mattwran
83 - rsa1
83 - tacman88
Games
Hot Top 20
Last 60 Days. BOLD titles were also hot one year ago.
Hot Last Year
60 days prior to one year ago. BOLD titles are presently hot as well.
Most Users Posting
All-Time Top 50
310 - Advanced Squad Leader (1985)
229 - Commands & Colors: Ancients (2006)
212 - Combat Commander: Europe (2006) Thumbs Up!
173 - Commands & Colors: Napoleonics (2010)
171 - Paths of Glory (1999)
126 - Here I Stand (2006)
119 - Memoir '44 (2004) Thumbs Up!
117 - Labyrinth: The War on Terror, 2001 – ? (2010) Thumbs Up!
112 - Sekigahara: The Unification of Japan (2011)
112 - Washington's War (2010)
109 - World in Flames (1985)
105 - Empire of the Sun (2005)
104 - Fighting Formations: Grossdeutschland Motorized Infantry Division (2011) Thumbs Up!
100 - No Retreat! The Russian Front (2011)
97 - Wilderness War (2001)
96 - D-Day at Omaha Beach (2009) Thumbs Up!
93 - Twilight Struggle (2005) Thumbs Up!
92 - Napoleon's Triumph (2007)
90 - Cuba Libre (2013)
88 - For the People (1998)
87 - Churchill (2015) Thumbs Up!
87 - Fire in the Lake (2014) Thumbs Up!
85 - Normandy '44 (2010)
83 - Advanced Squad Leader: Starter Kit #1 (2004) Thumbs Up!
82 - Unconditional Surrender! World War 2 in Europe (2014)
79 - Red Winter: The Soviet Attack at Tolvajärvi, Finland – 8-12 December 1939 (2012) Thumbs Up!
79 - Shifting Sands (2006)
79 - Warriors of God (2008)
78 - Hold the Line (2008)
78 - Triumph & Tragedy (2015)
77 - Band of Brothers: Screaming Eagles (2011) Thumbs Up!
76 - Hearts and Minds: Vietnam 1965-1975 (2010)
76 - Julius Caesar (2010)
68 - Liberty Roads (2009)
66 - A Distant Plain (2013)
66 - The Guns of Gettysburg (2013)
66 - Virgin Queen (2012)
65 - B-17: Queen of the Skies (1981)
65 - Cataclysm: A Second World War (2018)
65 - Squad Leader (1977)
64 - Up Front (1983)
63 - Hands in the Sea (2016) Thumbs Up!
62 - Andean Abyss (2012)
62 - FAB: The Bulge (2008)
62 - Fields of Fire (2008) Thumbs Up!
62 - Hammer of the Scots (2002)
61 - Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage (1996)
59 - The Civil War (1983)
59 - The U.S. Civil War (2015)
59 - Unhappy King Charles! (2008)